awareretailgroup.com

How Do You Measure Lockup Impact on Sales?

A lockup test puts a locked SKU, such as a razor pack behind a case key, into a controlled comparison against matched stores where the same item sits open on the shelf. Over a set window, such as the 13-week follow-up the Keeper boxes trial used (CrimeSolutions), the test tracks shrink dollars saved against gross margin lost to slower sales, key requests and labor time.

Where Does the 15% to 25% Lockup Sales-Loss Number Come From?

The 15% to 25% figure for lockup-driven sales loss comes from Joe Budano, CEO of the anti-theft technology company Indyme, who told Axios that locked cases can cause sales to drop 15% to 25% (Axios). CBS News reports Walgreens locked up more products after finding retail theft accounted for a rising share of its shrink (CBS News). NRF Vice President David Johnston takes the sharper position: lockup decisions should rest on “internal factors, not external statistics, using similar internal analyses as when the measures were first implemented” (LP Magazine). A chain that budgets lockup sales loss off a vendor’s range is skipping the internal analysis Johnston describes.

What Do Randomized Store Trials Show About Lockups and Sales?

The strongest evidence on protecting high-theft products comes from controlled trials. In a 57-store randomized trial, Hayes, Downs and Blackwood found anti-theft fixtures reduced losses by 56 percent and anti-theft procedures reduced losses by 58 percent compared with untreated control stores, with both treatments judged “efficacious and cost-effective” (OJP). A separate 10-store trial on plastic Keeper boxes, clear polycarbonate cases built to protect items like razor blades, found shrinkage fell 52 percent while sales rose 69 percent at the 13-week follow-up in stores using the boxes compared with control stores (CrimeSolutions). That trial, published in Security Journal in 2011 (Security Journal), tested a single hot-product category, razor blades, so its sales gain may not carry over to every locked SKU. Both studies split real stores into treatment and control groups, and the Keeper boxes trial measured shrink and sales side by side. Pick comparable stores, split them, and measure both sides of the ledger before any SKU goes behind glass.

How do I run a lockup test that shows whether locking a SKU costs more in sales than it saves in shrink?

Pick stores matched on format, volume and baseline shrink on the SKU in question, then randomly assign them to a locked group and a control group that leaves the item open, as the published trials randomized their stores. Hold the window to at least 13 weeks, the period the Keeper boxes trial used before shrinkage fell 52 percent and sales rose 69 percent against control stores (CrimeSolutions). Track only the test SKUs in both groups: units sold, dollars of shrink, key requests and the minutes an associate spends walking a key to the case. At the end of the window, net the shrink dollars prevented against the gross margin lost to slower sales and the labor spent on key requests. The fixtures trial reports its result on the loss side, a 56 percent reduction against untreated stores (OJP); your test adds the sales and labor side. Let that net number decide whether the case stays.

Which SKUs Belong Behind a Locked Case?

Not every stolen item justifies a locked case, because shopper patience varies by category. In a Numerator survey of more than 5,000 consumers fielded in September 2024, only 53% of shoppers said they would wait for assistance on locked bath and body products, 56% for makeup and cosmetics, and 57% for personal hygiene products (Chain Store Age). Compare that against the Keeper boxes trial discussed above, where protecting a genuine hot product, razor blades, drove a sales increase against control stores (CrimeSolutions). LPRC research director Cory Lowe reported that a survey of nearly 800 individuals found locking cases “widely disliked for their inconvenience” (LP Magazine). Reserve locked protection for items with real theft velocity, and test lighter protection before putting bath and body, cosmetics and hygiene products behind an associate key.

How Should a Store Staff the Key So a Locked Case Doesn’t Kill the Sale?

A locked case sells only when an associate can open it quickly. LPRC’s Cory Lowe said locking cases can be the only option for a retailer to do business, but warned that retailers “need the right type of locking cases, the right staffing levels, and the right communications and awareness technologies to make it easy for workers to know when someone needs assistance to unlock cases for them” (LP Magazine). Lowe added that unlock requests can be sent to staff radios, or that lights can be placed above call buttons so workers can see where the customer is (LP Magazine). Home Depot’s Scott Glenn said its QR-code scan lock boxes let customers reach staff and get serviced in under ninety seconds on average, a figure reported with no baseline for comparison (LP Magazine). RILA’s Khristopher Hamlin said “lockups introduce friction, and friction directly impacts conversion” (LP Magazine). Treat key response time as a service metric owned by store operations.

When Should a Lockup Come Down?

A lockup decision should carry its own exit terms. Home Depot’s Scott Glenn said the company has “removed some locking fixtures on certain products and in some markets as theft demand has fallen” (LP Magazine). Write exit criteria before the case goes up. Target’s own numbers, part of the broader picture of what counts as retail shrink, show why that discipline matters. CFO Michael Fiddelke reported that 2023 shrink cost rose more than $500 million versus 2022, about 50 basis points of incremental rate pressure, and that shrink costs cut operating margin by a cumulative 1.2 percentage points over four years compared with 2019 (Target). Set a review date when the case goes up, and require the net-value worksheet to justify keeping it past that date.

What Should a Lock-or-Not Worksheet Include?

The worksheet below turns the two randomized trials and the Numerator survey into a decision tool. Line A is shrink dollars prevented at cost, measured in your own test stores; the fixtures trial shows this line can be large (OJP). Line B is margin recovered from better in-stock sales; the Keeper boxes trial discussed above (CrimeSolutions) shows this line can be positive for a protected hot product, so measure it rather than assume it for a staffed aisle case. Line C is margin lost to a slower sale, grounded in the Numerator finding that only 53% of shoppers will wait for help on locked bath and body items (Chain Store Age). Lines D and E are store-specific inputs: associate minutes per case opening times loaded wage, and monthly fixture and maintenance cost. Run actual figures through the retail shrink calculator rather than guessing at them.

Line Factor Treatment
A Shrink dollars prevented at cost Add
B Margin recovered from better in-stock sales Add
C Margin lost to slower conversion on the locked SKU Subtract
D Associate minutes per case opening times loaded wage Subtract
E Monthly fixture and maintenance cost Subtract
Net A plus B minus C minus D minus E Keep if positive, expand if positive and growing, remove if negative

Frequently asked questions

How long should a lockup test run before the results can be trusted?

Plan on a baseline period plus at least 13 weeks with the locked case in place before comparing results. The Keeper boxes researchers collected 9 weeks of pretest data and 13 weeks of posttest data before comparing the locked stores against control stores (CrimeSolutions).

How many stores does a lockup test need for a trustworthy result?

Published trials offer a range. The fixtures and procedures study was a 57-store randomized trial comparing two treatments with untreated control stores (OJP), while the Keeper boxes trial used 10 stores (Security Journal). Match format and volume before splitting stores rather than chasing a specific count.

What do shoppers actually do when they find an item locked?

In the August 2023 Prosper survey of 8,185 respondents analyzed by Northwestern's Medill Spiegel Research Center, just over two in five shoppers who hit a locked item said they go ahead and buy it anyway (Medill). Just over one-third said they are unlikely to return to that store (Medill).

What is the difference between a before-and-after comparison and a true lockup test?

A before-and-after look at one store cannot separate a lockup's effect from a seasonal swing or a local theft trend. A design that randomly assigns stores to locked and control groups, as the Keeper boxes trial did (CrimeSolutions), isolates the effect by comparing locked stores against stores that changed nothing.

Sources

  • ojp.gov https://ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/anti-theft-procedures-and-fixtures-randomized-controlled-trial-two
  • crimesolutions.ojp.gov https://crimesolutions.ojp.gov/ratedprograms/keeper-boxes
  • link.springer.com https://link.springer.com/article/10.1057/sj.2011.2
  • losspreventionmedia.com https://losspreventionmedia.com/to-lock-or-not-to-lock/
  • losspreventionmedia.com https://losspreventionmedia.com/technology-alone-will-not-solve-the-problem/
  • chainstoreage.com https://chainstoreage.com/numerator-locked-goods-can-lead-lost-sales
  • corporate.target.com https://corporate.target.com/getmedia/a12513e5-e3d3-4561-909c-87b22a13c657/TGT-USQ_Transcript_2024-03-05.pdf
  • spiegel.medill.northwestern.edu https://spiegel.medill.northwestern.edu/retail-theft-and-consumers/
  • cbsnews.com https://www.cbsnews.com/news/walgreens-lock-product-up-sales/
  • axios.com https://www.axios.com/2023/02/20/shoplifting-store-closings-price-increases-locked-cases