awareretailgroup.com

How Do You Prevent a Robbery at Opening and Closing?

The risk at opening and closing is the moment a store can run on a single worker, such as a closer counting a drawer alone after the doors lock. Two-person open and close removes that lone-worker exposure, backed by a safe neither the opener nor closer can open on demand, so a worker deposits cash but cannot retrieve it (NIOSH). LP should confirm stores actually follow the procedure, since one study of Dallas and Houston convenience stores found only 9% were in full compliance with local security ordinances (CDC).

What makes opening and closing a high-exposure window?

Calling opening and closing the riskiest robbery times goes further than the timing research supports. A 1997 analysis cited by NIOSH found that 59% of convenience store robberies happened between 9 p.m. and 3 a.m., though that data covers one store format (NIOSH). LP Magazine notes that many robberies occur during daylight business hours (LP Magazine). What opening and closing can share is exposure: a worker who may be alone, with few customers around. The Houston Police Department flags suspicious people or vehicles around the business as especially worth watching at opening and closing, and warns that dumpsters are prime places where robbers hide while waiting (Houston Police Department). In one documented case, a cashier working alone had access to the safe that held the till at closing time, and the store had no workplace violence prevention or robbery response program (LP Magazine). Lone work and a reachable safe are the two conditions a solo open or close puts together. Pair staffing changes with clear guidance on what an associate does if a robbery happens anyway, covered in what a store associate should do during a robbery.

How should two-person open and close work in practice?

Houston Police Department guidance states plainly that two employees should open and close the business (Houston Police Department). Florida law gives convenience stores with a qualifying crime history the option of keeping at least two employees on the premises between 11 p.m. and 5 a.m. (Florida Statutes § 812.173). A case-control study of North Carolina workplaces (Loomis et al.) found eliminating solo work at night could reduce a worker’s risk of homicide (POP Center), though the POP Center’s guide on convenience store robbery calls research on two-clerk staffing inconsistent and highly debated (POP Center). OSHA’s late-night retail guidance asks whether workers have at least one other person with them, or other protective measures, when working alone in a high-crime location with a history of robberies or assaults (OSHA). A policy that requires two people only “when possible” has no floor. Require a manager’s written sign-off for any exception. On a normal two-person close, both workers leave together, the buddy system Loss Prevention Media recommends for leaving after dark (LP Magazine).

How does a drop, cash-control, or time-lock safe keep cash out of reach at opening and closing?

Three devices can sit behind the word “safe,” and the names overlap: the POP Center uses drop safe as another name for a cash-control unit. A drop safe, as NIOSH describes it, lets an employee deposit cash with no option to retrieve it, and the worker typically has no code to open it (NIOSH). A cash-control unit, the time-delay device, also takes deposits, with access controlled by keys or PINs, but it opens or dispenses cash only after a built-in delay, which the POP Center says is likely to deter an anxious robber (POP Center). A time-lock safe is stricter: it cannot be opened until specified times (NIOSH).

Device What it does Can the opener or closer retrieve cash on demand?
Drop safe Takes deposits; no retrieval option built in No, if it has no dispense function and neither holds the code
Cash-control unit Takes deposits; access by key or PIN; opens or dispenses on a delay Only after the delay
Time-lock safe Stays locked until a set time Not before the set time; schedule the unlock for a fully staffed shift

Which cash stays reachable depends on the policy wrapped around the hardware. Florida requires convenience businesses to post a notice at the entrance stating “the cash register contains $50 or less” and to adopt a cash management policy limiting cash on hand after 11 p.m. (Florida Statutes § 812.173). OSHA’s late-night retail checklist asks whether a site keeps less than $50 in the register, noting that figure may not be possible in stores that have lottery tickets and payouts (OSHA). Washington requires covered stores to post a notice on a window or door that, among other statements, says “Employees have no access to the safe” (Washington WAC 296-832), and that sign is only true if the drop or time-lock mechanism actually blocks both the opener and the closer from the main cash, not just the register drawer. LP Magazine’s situational-crime-prevention piece argues for reducing accessible cash as much as possible at all times (LP Magazine).

The Loomis et al. study in JAMA points the same way but does not settle it: workplaces where workers could open the safe had an adjusted odds ratio of 1.3 for worker homicide, and workplaces using a drop box workers could not open had 0.5, but neither result reached statistical significance (POP Center). Set the register limit to the figure on the entrance notice, drop anything above it during the shift, and give neither the opener nor the closer a code that releases safe cash immediately. That can remove the reason to target the lone employee at the door, though the POP Center cautions that an offender after fast money may not be dissuaded by a limited-cash sign (POP Center).

How can LP verify that two-person opens and closes actually happen?

OSHA’s late-night retail guidance states that “administrative controls work only if they are followed,” and that employers should monitor workers regularly to confirm proper work practices are in use (OSHA). The gap between policy and practice can be wide: a compliance study of Dallas and Houston convenience stores found that only 9% of stores were in full compliance with local security ordinances, even though 79% reported being registered with the police departments as compliant (CDC). Robberies at Houston convenience stores fell significantly after the city’s ordinance took effect, yet no individual safety measure was associated with lower robbery rates (CDC). The POP Center’s broader review of convenience store robbery makes a related point: prevention recommendations are effective only if properly implemented (POP Center). LP should treat two-person open and close like any control that depends on a human doing it every time: require each of the two employees to enter their own alarm code at open and close, compare the user codes and timestamps against the posted schedule, and spot-check camera footage at a handful of stores, an exercise closely tied to a store security self-audit.

Open and close procedure checklist for store managers

Use this list as the manager’s check against each week’s schedule.

Frequently asked questions

What is a closing checklist?

A closing checklist is a written sequence of steps a closer and manager confirm before leaving a store, covering cash security, door locks, alarm arming, and a walk-through of back rooms and restrooms so no one is hiding inside before the final lock-up.

Are opening and closing the highest-risk times for a store robbery?

Timing figures are thin and old. NIOSH cites a 1997 convenience-store analysis putting 59% of robberies from 9 p.m. to 3 a.m. (NIOSH), and an LP Magazine piece on situational crime prevention points to robberies taking place in daylight store hours too (LP Magazine). Plan for lone-worker exposure at open and close regardless of hour.

Does Washington's late-night retail rule apply to every store open at night?

Washington's WAC 296-832 covers any retail business operating between 11 p.m. and 6 a.m. (Washington WAC 296-832), but the chapter does not apply to restaurants, hotels, taverns, and lodging facilities. Stores it does cover need a drop-safe, limited access safe, or comparable device.

What should a store do when a two-person close genuinely isn't possible?

When staffing can't cover two people, require a manager's approval before any solo close, and arrange a security escort to the parking area, which OSHA's late-night retail guidance recommends for evening or late hours (OSHA). The lone closer should also hold no code that opens the safe.

Sources

  • osha.gov https://www.osha.gov/sites/default/files/publications/OSHA3153.pdf
  • cdc.gov https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2023-121/2023-121.pdf
  • leg.state.fl.us https://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0800-0899%2F0812%2FSections%2F0812.173.html
  • app.leg.wa.gov https://app.leg.wa.gov/wac/default.aspx?cite=296-832&full=true
  • popcenter.asu.edu https://popcenter.asu.edu/sites/g/files/litvpz3631/files/114-loomis_et_al-effectiveness_of_safety_mearures_recommende.pdf
  • popcenter.asu.edu https://popcenter.asu.edu/content/robbery-convenience-stores-page-3-0
  • houstontx.gov https://www.houstontx.gov/police/robbery/business.htm
  • stacks.cdc.gov https://stacks.cdc.gov/view/cdc/38332
  • stacks.cdc.gov https://stacks.cdc.gov/view/cdc/155540
  • losspreventionmedia.com https://losspreventionmedia.com/tips-for-keeping-c-store-cashiers-safe-from-robberies/
  • losspreventionmedia.com https://losspreventionmedia.com/leveraging-situational-crime-prevention-to-combat-retail-crime-and-loss/