awareretailgroup.com

What Are the Types of Workplace Violence in Retail Training?

A grocery cashier facing a customer screaming about a declined coupon is in a different situation than the same cashier facing a masked man demanding the register drawer, even though both can turn violent in the same aisle. Researchers sort incidents into four categories by the perpetrator’s relationship to the store (a criminal stranger, a customer or client, a coworker, or someone with a personal tie to an employee), because each type calls for a different prevention approach.

How does an associate tell in the first seconds whether it’s a customer dispute, a robbery or an active assailant?

Relationship is often not visible in the first seconds, so apparent intent is the faster cue. In a Type 1 incident, the person has “no legitimate relationship to the business or its employees” (University of Iowa IPRC). A Type 1 offender can open with a demand for the register, the safe, or merchandise, and may show a weapon before saying a word. A Type 2 customer can voice a grievance tied to one transaction before anything physical happens. A Type 3 incident involves someone who “is an employee or past employee of the business who attacks or threatens another employee(s)” (University of Iowa IPRC). A Type 4 incident arrives from outside with “a personal relationship with the intended victim” (University of Iowa IPRC).

Type Relationship to the store Possible first sign Retail example
Type 1, criminal intent No legitimate relationship Demand for cash, merchandise, or access Stranger demanding the register drawer
Type 2, customer or client Legitimate customer or client A grievance voiced before any action Shopper upset over a declined return
Type 3, worker-on-worker Current or past employee A known prior conflict surfacing A terminated employee confronting a shift lead
Type 4, personal relationship Personal tie to an employee, not the business Asking for a specific employee by name An ex-partner showing up at a register

These cues are inferred from the type definitions, not taken from a retail study, and a real incident may not follow them. Active assailant is the exception to relationship cues: the FBI defines it by behavior, someone “actively engaged in killing or attempting to kill people in a populated area” (FBI), so the cue is what the person is doing, not who they are. When it is unclear which type is unfolding, the associate’s role is to observe and report: step back and alert a manager. If a weapon appears alongside a demand for cash or merchandise, treat it as a robbery and follow the store’s robbery response rather than continuing the conversation.

Where did the four-type system come from?

Cal/OSHA’s 1995 guidelines divided workplace violence into three major types (Cal/OSHA’s 1995 guidelines), separating Type I’s irregular criminal events from Type II violence, which the guidelines said “occur on a daily basis in many service establishments.” In 2001, the University of Iowa Injury Prevention Research Center described four categories, in a report that thanked the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health for the funding that made its workshop possible (University of Iowa IPRC). California later numbered those same four categories into Labor Code 6401.9. NIOSH’s own pages do not agree on where the system came from: one NIOSH-hosted nurse training course credits “UIIPRC, 2001” for the four types (CDC), while a separate NIOSH learning page cites “(NIOSH, 2013)” for the identical four categories (CDC). A 2024 paper from NIOSH researchers states that the typology was developed in 2001 to sort violence by the perpetrator’s intent and relationship to the victim (CDC). The 2001 University of Iowa report is the earliest of these sources to set out the four-type form.

Why do workplace-violence numbers differ across sources?

Two frequently cited shares of Type 1 violence describe different things. The 2001 report’s founding number, drawn from 1997 US data, put the criminal-intent share of workplace homicides at about 85% (University of Iowa IPRC). Cal/OSHA’s earlier 1995 guidelines reported a narrower number: 60% of California workplace homicides at the time involved someone entering a small late-night retail establishment to commit a robbery (Cal/OSHA’s 1995 guidelines). One is a national, multi-industry figure; the other is California-only, late-night-retail-only, and from the early 1990s. The 2001 University of Iowa report puts the number of American workers who are victims of workplace violence at some 2 million a year, an older estimate (University of Iowa IPRC). The federal figure for 2015 to 2019 is 1.3 million nonfatal violent crimes in the workplace annually, with strangers committing about 47% of them (BJS); because it counts crimes rather than victims, it is not directly comparable to the 2001 estimate. One 2024 NIOSH analysis estimates tending retail accounted for 29% of 2021 workplace homicides by worker activity, with protective services next at 19% (CDC).

What do Type 3 and Type 4 look like in a retail store?

The University of Iowa report puts worker-on-worker violence at about 7% of all workplace homicides (University of Iowa IPRC), describing it as an employee or past employee who attacks or threatens another employee. A register is a fixed location, so a person with a personal tie to a cashier can know where to find them. Cal/OSHA’s own general-industry page describes “a convenience store employee” who “can be fatally injured at the workplace during a robbery (Type 1), or because of a personal dispute with a non-employee (Type 3)” (Cal/OSHA), a label that conflicts with Labor Code 6401.9’s own Type 4 definition for the identical scenario. A store manager completing a California incident log should follow the statute’s numbering over the agency’s own webpage example.

Why isn’t active assailant just Type 1?

Active assailant describes how violence escalates once it starts; the relationship that triggered it can come from any of the four types. The FBI defines an active shooter as “one or more individuals actively engaged in killing or attempting to kill people in a populated area” (FBI), a definition built on behavior rather than on who the attacker is to the business. The FBI documented a 2025 shooting at a Walgreens in Madera, California, where a man with a handgun shot people inside the store and killed one person (FBI). The same lethal behavior could also come from a Type 3 coworker returning after a termination or a Type 4 personal relationship arriving at the register. CISA says there is “no one-size-fits-all response approach for active assailant situations” (CISA). A store cannot key one procedure to a single relationship type. For the broader plan structure, see what a retail store emergency action plan should cover.

How do California and New York differ in how they classify the types?

California numbers its four types in statute: Labor Code 6401.9 requires the incident log to record “the workplace violence type or types” (FindLaw) for every incident, and requires “initial training when the plan is first established, and annually thereafter” on the section’s definitions and requirements, which include the four types (FindLaw). New York’s Department of Labor FAQ lists the four perpetrator categories in words and says an employee reporting system is not required but is a recommended best practice (NYSDOL). New York’s law “only covers employers with 10 or more retail employees in New York State” (NYSDOL). In practice, associates need the categories mainly to choose a response, and leadership records the formal type afterward. California’s standards board must adopt its workplace-violence rule by December 31, 2026 (FindLaw); New York’s employers with 500 or more employees must give workers a silent response button by January 1, 2027 (NYSDOL). Full cadence requirements sit in what California SB 553 requires a manager to train and the New York Retail Worker Safety Act’s timeline.

California (Labor Code 6401.9) New York (Retail Worker Safety Act)
Types numbered in statute Yes, Type 1 through Type 4 Four categories listed in the FAQ
Incident log must record type Yes Not stated in the FAQ
Who is covered All employers except those the statute exempts, such as certain health care operations and some small non-public workplaces Only employers with 10 or more retail employees
2026-2027 deadline Standards board rule due December 31, 2026 Silent response button due January 1, 2027, applies to employers with 500+ employees

What should a store manager check before training on this?

A session built on relationship and intent, rather than type numbers, needs a few pieces in place before the huddle starts. Store leaders should know which category label their own state’s law uses before an associate ever has to describe an incident out loud, and associates should know that assigning the formal type is leadership’s job. The list below turns the framework into something a shift lead can run through in five minutes.

Pair this checklist with the store’s existing robbery response steps and de-escalation training, since it only decides which one to reach for first.

Frequently asked questions

What are the four types of workplace violence?

Occupational researchers group workplace violence by the offender's connection to the business: someone with no tie to the store, a shopper or client, a present or former coworker, or a person connected personally to an employee. California numbers the four in Labor Code 6401.9; New York's labor department lists them in words.

What is level 3 workplace violence?

The four-type systems described here use Type I through IV (or Type 1 through 4), not levels. If someone means Type III, that is worker-on-worker violence, which the University of Iowa's 2001 report ties to roughly 7% of workplace homicides (University of Iowa IPRC).

What signals that a customer dispute has turned into something more dangerous?

A grievance that suddenly includes a demand for property, or the appearance of a weapon, marks a shift away from a dispute. The associate steps back and alerts a manager, and a weapon shown with a demand for property calls for the store's robbery response, not more conversation at the register.

What are some examples of violence-prevention measures retailers are using right now?

Retailers reported increasing management training (72%), employee training (65%) and risk-intelligence technology (61%) as workplace-violence safety measures in 2026 (NRF). Those figures show adoption levels only; they say nothing about which measure reduced incidents or how associates rated each one on the floor.

Sources

  • iprc.public-health.uiowa.edu https://iprc.public-health.uiowa.edu/wp-content/uploads/2015/09/workplace-violence-report-1.pdf
  • dir.ca.gov https://www.dir.ca.gov/dosh/Workplace-Violence/General-Industry.html
  • ucop.edu https://www.ucop.edu/risk-services/_files/bsas/safetymeetings/cal_oshaviolence.pdf
  • wwwn.cdc.gov https://wwwn.cdc.gov/WPVHC/Nurses/Course/Slide/Unit1_5
  • cdc.gov https://www.cdc.gov/niosh/learning/safetyculturehc/module-2/10.html
  • stacks.cdc.gov https://stacks.cdc.gov/view/cdc/156329/cdc_156329_DS1.pdf
  • bjs.ojp.gov https://bjs.ojp.gov/content/pub/pdf/iwv19.pdf
  • fbi.gov https://www.fbi.gov/file-repository/reports-and-publications/active-shooter-incidents-in-the-us-2025.pdf
  • cisa.gov https://www.cisa.gov/sites/default/files/2025-02/Instructional_Guide_to_the_CISA_EAP_Template_20250204_508.pdf
  • codes.findlaw.com https://codes.findlaw.com/ca/labor-code/lab-sect-6401-9/
  • dol.ny.gov https://dol.ny.gov/retail-worker-safety-act-frequently-asked-questions
  • nrf.com https://nrf.com/research/the-impact-of-retail-theft-violence-2026