awareretailgroup.com

What Is Sweethearting in Retail, and How Do You Spot It at the Register?

What is sweethearting in retail?

Sweethearting is a cashier passing merchandise to a friend, relative or accomplice without ringing it up correctly, such as scanning nine items in a ten-item cart and letting the tenth go unscanned for a former coworker. NRF’s 2023 survey lists passing off merchandise to friends (sweethearting, sliding, free bagging) among the top four reported internal-theft methods, alongside merchandise theft, refund fraud and cash/deposit theft (NRF). Exception reports flag voids, overrides and discounts; an unscanned item creates none of those, so register video has to cover it.

How does a cashier run sweethearting without touching the till?

Adrian Beck’s research for ECR Retail Loss drew on interviews with offenders in 74 cases that generated data on 99 dishonest events, most of them in stores (ECR Retail Loss). Of those cases, 47 involved till operators and another 12 worked mainly on the shop floor; the till was where the vast majority of incidents happened, 68 of the 99 (ECR Retail Loss). Taking cash was the most frequent till method, followed by non-scanning of items for family, friends and colleagues (ECR Retail Loss). Relatively few till offenders tried to conceal their tracks by manipulating the till (ECR Retail Loss). These figures come from older UK interviews with offenders, so treat them as a pattern to test in your own stores. A program that only chases suspicious voids and discount overrides can miss an offender who simply does not scan an item. That gap is why register video review belongs alongside the internal theft exception report.

What should a weekly exception report flag?

LPRC authors writing in Loss Prevention Magazine describe a well-designed exception-based reporting program as one that “can analyze massive amounts of POS and operational data to identify anomalies, such as voids, returns, discounts, overrides, and unusual no-sale transactions” (LP Magazine). The same authors note, “we would expect a supervisor or manager to engage in far more of these types of activities,” so a flat average across all employees can flag supervisors for normal activity (LP Magazine). ECR Retail Loss lists staff sharing till PIN numbers or skipping the log-off step at shift end among the vulnerable processes it found (ECR Retail Loss). The LPRC authors add that “comparing POS login activity with time clock data can expose when employees may be using others’ credentials” (LP Magazine). For broader register controls beyond this one check, see how do you reduce employee theft at the register.

A weekly pull should look like this:

What the sweethearting research does and doesn’t measure

Michael Brady, Clay Voorhees and Michael Brusco published their study in the Journal of Marketing (FSU), drawing on dyadic data from 171 service employees and 610 of their customers (LP Magazine). The study surveyed service employees and customers, not a count of theft incidents in retail stores. Separately, Adrian Beck’s ECR Retail Loss data on actual offenders found cash theft outranked non-scanning as the most frequent till method (ECR Retail Loss), which cuts against treating sweethearting as the default answer. NRF has said a broad shrink study no longer captures the industry’s key challenges, and it announced a report on retail theft and violence in its place (Retail Dive). Treat any claim that sweethearting is the most common employee theft with caution, and verify the baseline for your own chain.

Why sweethearting can quietly inflate customer satisfaction scores

Richard Hollinger, summarizing the Brady, Voorhees and Brusco research in Loss Prevention Magazine, writes that “not accounting for sweethearting in the customer experience could significantly inflate customer satisfaction scores, loyalty levels, and positive word-of-mouth opinions” (LP Magazine). That matters for any store that ties bonuses, scheduling preference or recognition programs to customer-survey scores: a cashier quietly comping a regular’s coffee or waving through a friend’s extra item can look, on paper, like exceptional service. Don’t let a survey score alone earn a bonus, scheduling preference or recognition; check register exceptions for the same shift first, since a flagged exception and a glowing customer comment can both be true about the same transaction.

How do you train associates on sweethearting without treating them as suspects, and what happens when you find it?

All four companies in Adrian Beck’s ECR Retail Loss study banned staff from serving family and friends outright, backed by disciplinary liability (ECR Retail Loss). A sample retail employee handbook states the same rule plainly: staff “are not permitted to ring up their own purchases or purchases made by members of their family and/or close personal friends” (retail employee handbook). Put that rule in writing, then brief it without accusation: tell cashiers it applies to everyone, that a friend or relative pays full price and rings up on a different register when one is open, and that declining a discount request is simply following policy. A short briefing script:

Any item that leaves the store without full payment through the register, including an unauthorized discount, a skipped scan or a free item for a friend, is a freebie, and policy prohibits it for every cashier. The rule protects you from being asked to choose between a friend and your job. If a friend asks, say: “Policy says I can’t ring you up, but anyone on the next register can.”

LPRC authors writing in Loss Prevention Magazine warn that heavy-handed messaging “can create a culture of distrust, which may worsen internal dishonesty by generating disengagement and resentment” (LP Magazine), so pair the rule with the openness ECR recommends: awareness programmes that highlight the business’s data mining and exception reporting capability, the scope of CCTV coverage, and the implications of being caught (ECR Retail Loss). When a flag becomes a real finding, investigate, document what was checked, and hand the file to HR and counsel. ECR Retail Loss reports that most companies prefer to deal with staff dishonesty internally, through dismissal, demotion or other disciplinary action (ECR Retail Loss). That handoff connects directly to how a store decides whether to prosecute or simply terminate a confirmed case, and to what legal rights apply during an employee theft investigation before anyone sits down with the cashier.

What to do this week

Frequently asked questions

Is sweethearting the same thing as shoplifting?

Shoplifting is committed by someone with no employment relationship to the store, while sweethearting requires an employee to complete the transaction. It also involves a second person, the friend, relative or accomplice who leaves with the goods. A confirmed finding goes to HR and counsel rather than register-level discipline.

What's the difference between sweethearting and refund fraud?

Refund fraud returns money or store credit for merchandise that was never actually given back, while sweethearting gives merchandise away at the point of sale without full payment changing hands. NRF's 2023 survey lists both among the top reported internal-theft methods.

Does self-checkout cut non-scanning compared with a cashier lane?

Self-checkout removes the cashier from the scan. In one US retailer's data, published by ECR Retail Loss, the researchers found manned checkout operators were three times more likely to not scan an item than self-scan customers (ECR Retail Loss), though that count mixes errors with deliberate misses and covers only one aspect of checkout activity.

Does sweethearting show up in shrink numbers?

NRF's 2023 survey reports internal (employee) theft at 29% of shrink loss, against 36% for external theft, based on respondents' own estimates of their losses (NRF). Sweethearting sits inside that internal-theft share, as one of the four methods respondents reported most.

Who should be told if sweethearting is confirmed at a register?

Bring in HR and counsel before any final decision, and keep the file to what was checked: the exception flags, the register video and the login record. ECR Retail Loss notes that most companies prefer to keep such cases in-house, ending them with firing, demotion or other discipline.

Sources

  • a-us.storyblok.com https://a-us.storyblok.com/f/1021220/x/ce11a3e264/nrf_-national_retail_security_survey_2023.pdf
  • ecrloss.com https://ecrloss.com/research-paper/reduce-employee-theft-in-retail/
  • losspreventionmedia.com https://losspreventionmedia.com/how-to-detect-internal-dishonesty/
  • losspreventionmedia.com https://losspreventionmedia.com/sweethearting-the-dark-side-of-good-customer-service/
  • ecrloss.com https://www.ecrloss.com/research/the-impact-and-control-of-shrinkage-at-self-scan-checkouts/
  • retaildive.com https://www.retaildive.com/news/no-nrf-annual-retail-shrink-report-2024/729009/
  • wertheim.fsu.edu https://wertheim.fsu.edu/person/michael-brady
  • recruiting.adp.com https://recruiting.adp.com/portal-upload/RTI_1135707/htmlassets/Retail-Onboarding/Retail_Handbook_Rev_8-2016.pdf?x=0.9592760306779073